Abby continues her life in New York City. Her life feels hollow and empty. The happy, satirical, and outgoing persona she projects is just a mask. But no one can see through the facade.
Abby works as a secretary to the esteemed artist. Their relationship is simple and uncomplicated, but when he asks her out, she immediately rejects him.
Alexandra and Blaise move to the city so they can continue their education. Alexandra is finally in medical school, and Blaise is pursuing his dream to be a lawyer. The happiness they share makes Abby feel even worse. Eventually, Alexandra pushes Abby to give Fernan a chance. And she doesn't regret it.
Paul is still healing from the breakup but he isn't handling it very well. In secret, Abby consoles him. But she's also trying to nurse herself back together. When she meets his brother, Toby, fists immediately fly. They don't get along. All they do is bicker and argue.
Until Abby starts to feel differently...
Caught between two men that make her happier than she expected, she must decide who's better suited for her. Who's is her soul mate and who's the love of her life?